This is an important point and if we lose sight of it we lose sight of the poem and of what makes it historically significant. Judging contemporary characters, through lyrical poetry, in consultation with the classics on a question that transcends his own time and place I feel qualifies the comedy as a work of great historical significance. However let us not digress untimely, rather I will now examine the contemporary experience which Dante's.
Get Access. Read More. Divine Comedy - The Trinity in Dante's Inferno Essay Words 9 Pages Trinity in The Inferno Dante's Inferno, itself one piece of a literary trilogy, repeatedly deploys the leitmotif of the number three as a metaphor for ambiguity, compromise, and transition.
Purgatorio Essay Words 18 Pages consideration of Purgatorio is not its beginning but its middle. Share this Article. You are free to share this article under the Attribution 4. What is the value of film interpretations of classical work? What influence did Dante have on the Reformation? And how has he sustained such popularity? How hell shaped early American politics. Stay Connected. Subscribe to our Newsletter. Add your information below to receive daily updates.
Sign Up. Characters Dante Alighieri. Previous section Character List Next section Virgil. Popular pages: Inferno. Take a Study Break. For Dante there are four main features of any mode of expression appropriate for these tasks. That such a language can generate virtues in human beings is precisely what Dante means in 1.
And, in 1. To illustrate the significance of this style of argumentation, it is worth backing up for a moment to see that prior to defining the four main features of any illustrious vernacular, Dante had already hunted for an illustrious vernacular among roughly fourteen existing regional species of the Italian mode of the vernacular. During the course of this hunt, however, Dante offered judgments regarding the deficiencies of various aesthetic features of these existing modes of the Italian vernacular as if he had already established the very principles that he articulated only after having abandoned that hunt.
For instance, after heaping scorn on the vernacular habits of his fellow Tuscans, Dante proceeds to the following evaluation of the Genoese:. The claim that an illustrious vernacular would not include frequent uses of the phoneme z is puzzling on the surface and seems to call for a justification much more robust than the judgment that z is a harsh sound. Indeed, Dante seems somewhat aware of this problem, for in 1.
Quite to the contrary, since the proper use of such a vernacular requires that a poet possesses both scientia et ingenium , those who are legitimate users of an illustrious vernacular are likely to be few in number, and the ways in which they ought to employ such a language are similarly constrained.
To see how this hint bears out it will help to recall the points that Dante offered in the Convivio about the relationship between philosophical, theological, and secular political authority. But, in fact, Dante pursues this line of thinking even further in Convivio 4. In Convivio 4. Philosophy qua philosophy is impotent in the task of guiding all but those who have already achieved both ethical and intellectual virtues.
Regardless of the uses to which it was later put, the Monarchia is in its own way as idiosyncratic as the Convivio. Its purpose, foreshadowed in the discussion of empire in Convivio IV, is to demonstrate the necessity of a single ruling power, reverent toward but independent of the Church, capable of ordering the will of collective humanity in peace and concord.
Under such a power the potential intellect of humanity can be fully actuated—the intellect, that is, of collective humanity, existent throughout the world, acting as one. For just as a multitude of species must continually be generated to actualize the full potentiality of prime matter, so the full intellectual capacity of humanity cannot be realized at one time nor in a single individual [ Mon.
Here Dante adds his own further particularization of this Aristotelian doctrine [ De Anima 3. The ordering of the collective human will to the goal of realizing its intellectual potential requires universal peace [1.
For Thomas this is only an analogy, a way of introducing the theme of order as it applies to the soul and its pursuit of happiness. The third book deals with the crucial issue of the relationship between political and ecclesiastical authority.
Dante argues on various grounds that power in the temporal realm is neither derived from nor dependent on spiritual authority, though it benefits from the power of the Papacy to bless its activity. These arguments consist largely in refutations of traditional claims for the temporal authority of the Papacy, but the final chapter makes the argument on positive grounds and in terms that recall the arguments first laid down in the Convivio.
Since man consists of soul and body, his nature partakes of both the corruptible and the incorruptible. Uniting two natures, his existence must necessarily be ordered to the goals of both these natures [ Mon.
Like the Averroistic reasoning of his earlier claim that only under a world empire can humanity realize its intellectual destiny, this crowning claim shows Dante appropriating Aristotle to the service of a unique and almost desperate vision of empire as a redemptive force.
Few texts have generated such deep and abiding interest as has the Divine Comedy in its nearly seven centuries of transmission. In part because of this seemingly encyclopedic character, but also because so many of the poetic stratagems of the Divine Comedy involve irony and outright paradox, any attempt to summarize its philosophical content or significance is to a certain degree an act of folly.
At the outset, it is worth dispensing with the notion that the Divine Comedy rejects philosophy in favor of what appears to be a mystical undertaking. In other words, the question of what philosophy means within the world described by the Divine Comedy probably should not rest upon a superficial identification of it with the fates of even those who are so easily taken to be its symbols. Indeed, already in the Convivio , Dante presents a complicated understanding of the meaning and scope of philosophy.
There, lady philosophy was depicted in books 2 and 3 as offering human beings the capacity for contemplative unity with God through their devotion to her. Hence, it is worth recalling a passage mentioned above in which Dante maintains that. In other words, the tension between the role of philosophy in the active life and its potential role for the contemplative life is broached in the Convivio in such a way that hints that the Divine Comedy , too, may be structured by the tension between its ambitions to make legitimate use of philosophy in these two related but fundamentally different manners—ways that may even be in tension with each other insofar as pursuit of one end may sometimes seem to preclude or require the abandonment of pursuit of the other.
First, there is the question of the how to interpret the explicit doctrinal claims of the various speakers in the Divine Comedy. Purgatorio 16, for instance, introduces Marco the Lombard on the terrace of wrath. But the culminating lines of his speech do little more than offer a brief summary of the political philosophy espoused in Convivio 4 and Monarchia.
Accordingly, read in light of the Convivio and the Monarchia , when Marco asserts in And, of course, this problem—the interpretive problem posed by the significance of the dramatic context for the various speeches in the Divine Comedy —is an inescapable feature of the hermeneutic framework within which philosophical and theological doctrines are offered for our consideration. Indeed, a great deal of scholarly attention and debate has centered around a handful of passages in the Divine Comedy that may be considered palinodes to Vita Nuova and Convivio [see, for example, Freccero ; Hollander , ; Jacoff, ; Pertile ; Scott , , ; Ascoli ; Dronke ; and Aleksander a].
This is because the poem is structured by the conviction that there can be no hope of achieving any of our possible perfections without constantly exposing ourselves, especially in our shared activity of reading, to the anxious experience of wonder—an experience that is heightened and sustained by simultaneously striving for philosophical rigor and acknowledging it limitations. Life 2. Early Poetry 3. Philosophical Influences 4.
The Convivio 5. The De vulgari eloquentia 6. The Monarchia 7. Philosophical Influences The philosophical content of the Vita nuova is minimal, a skeletal version of contemporary faculty psychology and a few brief references to metaphysics. As Santagata notes in his recent biography of Dante, Two great intellectuals who were readers at Santa Croce between and —Pietro di Giovanni Olivi from Provence, and the younger Ubertino da Casale—played a major role in the history of the Franciscan movement and, more generally, in the Church.
By enabling us to analyze the processes of perception, philosophy brings us into contact with the true nature of things, and for Dante, as Kenelm Foster observes, the slightest such contact could have a metaphysical value: It did not in one sense matter to Dante what the particular object of his knowing might be, since the joy of knowing it was already a foretaste of all conceivable knowledge and all joy; and this precisely because, in knowing, the mind seized truth…once intelligence, the truth-faculty, had tasted truth as such, that is, its own correspondence with reality, it could not help desiring truth whole and entire, that is, its correspondence with all reality.
The De vulgari eloquentia During the same period in which Dante was writing the Convivio he was also composing the De vulgari eloquentia. For instance, after heaping scorn on the vernacular habits of his fellow Tuscans, Dante proceeds to the following evaluation of the Genoese: If there is anyone who thinks that what I have just said about the Tuscans could not be applied to the Genoese, let him consider only that if, through forgetfulness, the people of Genoa lost the use of the letter z , they would either have to fall silent for ever or invent a new language for themselves.
For z forms the greater part of their vernacular, and it is, of course a letter that cannot be pronounced without considerable harshness. To me, however, the whole world is a homeland, like the sea to fish—though I drank from the Arno before cutting my teeth, and love Florence so much that, because I loved her suffer exile unjustly—and I will weight the balance of my judgment more with reason than with [sensation].
Philosophical authority is not opposed to imperial authority; but the latter without the former is dangerous, and the former without the latter is weak, as it were, not in itself but because of the disorder that results among the people; so that one combined with the other is highly useful and most valid. There are other laws which follow on nature, so to speak, as in establishing when a man is old enough to manage his own affairs, and where these are concerned we are not wholly subject.
Consequently, there is no obligation to believe or assent to the emperor Nero, who said that early adulthood was bodily beauty and strength, but [instead] to him, a philosopher [Aristotle], who said that early adulthood is the peak of natural life. Now these two kinds of happiness must be reached by different means, as representing different ends.
For we attain the first through the teachings of philosophy, provided that we follow them putting into practice the moral and intellectual virtues; whereas we attain the second through spiritual teachings which transcend human reason, provided that we follow them putting into practice the theological virtues, i. The Commedia The Divine Comedy Few texts have generated such deep and abiding interest as has the Divine Comedy in its nearly seven centuries of transmission.
Hence, it is worth recalling a passage mentioned above in which Dante maintains that it should be understood that the gaze of this woman was so liberally ordained for us, not only for seeing the countenance that she reveals to us, but for desiring to attain the things she keeps hidden.
Thus, because through her many of those things are seen by means of reason, and consequently can be seen, while without her they seem inexplicable and miraculous, so we believe through her that every miracle may have its reason in a higher intellect and consequently is possible. Giorgio Petrocchi, Florence: Le Lettere, Charles Singleton, 6 vols.
0コメント